Hotel Pennsylvania
by Independent
THINK TWICE
Proceed with caution
Multiple concerns detected. We recommend exploring alternatives in this market.
Fair — read the details
Poor — major issues
Low risk — stable brand history
Good
🔍 Truth Gaps Detected
Things that don't add up — where marketing may not match reality.
⚠️ 107-year-old property, no renovation found
This hotel was built in 1919 and we found no evidence of major renovation. Interiors may be significantly dated.
Classification
Year Built
1919
107 years old
Last Renovated
None found
107-year-old property
Current Brand
Independent
Evidence
76
13 sources
What Travelers Say
Third-party ratings shown for transparency. These are independent of our RoomTruth Score.
Why we think this
Every score is backed by evidence. Click into each to see exactly what we found.
Freshness
Poor · Moderate confidence
How new or recently updated is this hotel?
Built 1919 (107 years ago)
No renovation on record
Baseline estimate
Baseline
⚠ No renovation found for a 107-year-old property
Clean Stay
Fair · Moderate confidence
How likely are you to have a clean stay?
2 positive, 4 negative mentions
0 pest, 1 mold reports
1 maintenance complaints, 4 cleanliness complaints
2-star property adjustment (-5 points)
⚠ Mold/mildew mentioned (1 mention)
Rebrand Risk
Excellent · Moderate confidence
Is this a new brand on an old building?
Single brand on record
No brand change to evaluate
N/A
Brand and building aligned
Evidence
Good
How much do we actually know about this hotel?
13 data points
6/7 key fields populated
Initial ingestion data
No contradiction analysis yet
Property Timeline
Opened in 1919
Opened in 1919
Opened in 1919
Ready to decide?
Compare this hotel with others in the New York market, or book directly.
How we build these scores
Every score is computed from real evidence — official hotel records, press releases, OTA listings, and guest review analysis. We show our work: every factor, every source, every confidence level. We never fake certainty. If we don't have enough data, we tell you.